It's Friday, April 11, 1986, and the Pirates are hosting the Cubs in the first game of a three-game series at Three Rivers Stadium. Steve Trout will start for the Cubs, while Bob Kipper takes the ball for the Pirates. Bonds is in center field and will bat eighth, as his replacement Joe Orsulak did in real life. The Cubs won the actual game, 5-4.
Let's examine Bonds' at bats first:
In the first with one out and the Cubs already leading 5-0, shortstop Sammy Khalifa hit a bouncer to second that was muffed by the Cubs' Ryne Sandberg, allowing Khalifa to reach on an error. Johnny Ray singled to put two men on, and right fielder Mike Brown walked to load the bases. Mike Diaz, who was starting at first base, hit a fly ball to center that bounced off the glove of the Cubs' Bob Dernier and rolled past him. Khalifa scored, and the Bucs were on the board. Pena followed with a lined single to left that brought Ray home, and the Chicago lead was down to 5-2 with the bases still loaded.
A shaky Trout managed to get out of the inning without further damage, as Morrison's popup was caught by Ron Cey at third and Bonds' line drive was smothered by Leon Durham at first to retire the side,
In the bottom of the second, reliever Larry McWilliams led off with a single to left. Left fielder R.J. Reynolds smacked the first pitch he saw into the right center power alley for a double to put runners at second and third, and a walk to Khalifa loaded the bases. Ray forced Khalifa for out number one as McWilliams scored to make it 5-3, and right fielder Mike Brown's fly down the left field line was caught by Chicago's Gary Matthews for out number two.
Matthews hit shortstop Shawon Dunston with a perfect throw, but Dunston's relay to the plate was a hair late, and Reynolds scored the fourth Pittsburgh run while Ray moved to second. A wild pitch moved him to third, and Diaz gave the Bucs the lead by lining Trout's final pitch of the evening over the left field wall for a two-run homer, his fourteenth of the season, After two wild innings, it was Pirates 6, Cubs 5.
In the third, Bonds flew to shallow right center.
In the fifth, he lined to Durham at first,
In the seventh with the Cubs leading 14-6, Ray led off with a base hit to right center. Brown singled to left to put two men on, and Diaz doubled into the right center power alley to bring Ray home and make it 14-7. Brown stopped at third, and Cubs manager Jim Frey excused reliever Dick Ruthven in favor of Frank DiPino, who retired Pena on a wicked liner to Dunston at short as the runners held. Third baseman Jim Morrison's grounder to second brought Brown home with the eighth Pittsburgh run and moved Diaz to third, but Dunston speared another sizzler, this time from Bonds, to end the inning.
In the ninth, with the Pirates trailing 21-9 and the clock just striking midnight, Brown drew a leadoff walk. Diaz singled to left to put two men on, and Pena's single to left center loaded the bases. At that point, a future Hall of Famer made his major league debut, as Greg Maddux came out of the Chicago pen to face Morrison, who made it three straight singles with his bullet to right center. Brown and Diaz scored, Pena moved to third, and the Cubs' lead was 21-11. Bonds made it four hits in a row with a bloop single to right to bring Pena home and cut the Buccos' deficit to 21-12. Since he had no need for him as a closer, Leyland called on Donnie Robinson to bat for reliever Bob Patterson, and Donnie kept the line moving with a single to left that reloaded the bases.
Reynolds was next, and he walked on five pitches to bring Morrison home with run number thirteen for the Bucs. There was only one position player left on the Pirates bench: catcher Junior Ortiz, and Leyland went to him as the pinch hitter for Khalifa. Junior hit a rising line drive that figured to go over Dunston's head, but Shawon reached as high as he could and brought it down for out number one. Ray cued one right back to Maddux, and the rookie had the presence of mind to throw to the plate, where an incoming Bonds was tagged by Cubs catcher Jody Davis for the second out. Brown forced Ray to end the game after four hours and forty-nine minutes. Our final: Cubs 21, Pirates 13.
The Cubs started the madness with a five-run top of the first. Dernier lined a leadoff single to left against Kipper. Matthews walked to put two men on, and Matthews beat out a bouncer to Ray at second for an infield single to load the bases. Right fielder Keith Moreland was next, and he golfed Kipper's 1-2 fastball over the wall in right for a grand slam, his fourteenth homer of the year. First baseman Leon Durham grounded to Ray at second for out number one, but Davis smashed the first pitch he saw over the right field fence and halfway back to Chicago for his twenty-second home run of the year and a 5-0 Cubs lead. Estimated distance: 379 feet, (Right field is 335 feet away from home plate at Three Rivers.)
The Cubbies retied the game with a run in the top of the third. Durham lined a leadoff single to right and scored when Davis lined a double off the right field wall. We were tied at six after two and a half.
The visitors retook the lead with two runs in the top of the fifth. Davis drew a one-out walk, and third baseman Ron Cey beat out a grounder to second for an infield single. A wild pitch from McWilliams moved the runners up, and Dunston's lined shot into the gap in right center for a double brought them both home and put the Cubs up 8-6.
The Cubs blew the game open for the first time with four runs in the top of the sixth, With one out, Sandberg's bloop found friendly turf in left field for a single. Ryno then stole second, and walks to Moreland and Durham loaded the bases. After a chat with Pirates pitching coach Ray Miller, an exhausted McWilliams caught Davis looking at strike three for out number two. All Larry had to do to top off his evening was retire Cey. No such luck; The Penguin lashed the first pitch he saw into the left center power alley to clear the bases and extend the Chicago lead to 11-6. McWilliams gave way to Barry Jones, who was greeted by Dunston's single up the middle. Cey scored, and the Cubs led 12-6.
The North Siders tacked on two more runs with one out in the seventh. First, Sandberg drove Jones' 1-2 fastball over the right center field wall for Chicago run number thirteen. It was his fourteenth homer of the year. Moreland was next, and he went deep for the second time tonight with a majestic fly ball over the fence in left center, his fifteenth homer of the year. As we stretched at Three Rivers, it was Chicago 14, Pittsburgh 6.
The Cubs carried a 14-8 lead into the eighth, when they blew the game open for good. New pitcher Jim Wynn got the first two outs, but Dernier kept the inning alive with a single to right center. Walks to Matthews and Sandberg loaded the bases, and Moreland drove in his sixth and seventh runs of the night with a base hit to right center that drove in Dernier and Matthews to make it 16-8.
Winn proceeded to lose any concept of where the plate was; Durham walked to load the bases, Davis walked to force Sandberg home, and Cey walked to force Moreland home. After five walks and two hits in two-thirds of an inning. Winn exited to a deafening chorus of boos, jeers, and catcalls. Patterson was in for a rough beginning too, as Dunston's base hit up the middle scored Durham and Davis with Chicago runs nineteen and twenty. Reliever Matt Keough's grounder to Morrison at third ended the inning.
The Bucs got a run back in the last of the eighth, as Khalifa hit a 1-0 curve from Keough down the left field line and over the fence for his second home run of the year, both of which have come in these sims. After eight, the Cubs' lead was eleven at 20-9,
The Cubs got that run back against Patterson in the top of the ninth. Dernier drew a leadoff walk, and the Cubs hit blackjack when Matthews rang a double off the wall in left to bring him home.
Final stats: Cubs 21-20-2, Pirates 13-16-0.
W- Ruthven (1-0)
HR- CHC: Davis (22), Moreland 2 (15), Sandberg (14)
PIT: Diaz (14), Khalifa (2)
DW- Trout (4-7)
DS- L. Smith (30)
Bonds was one for five with an RBI. He's still batting .225 (122-543) with twenty home runs and sixty-five runs batted in.
Next: Game 2 between the Pirates and Cubs on Saturday, April 12. Scott Sanderson will start for the Cubs, while Rick Rhoden heads to the mound for the Pirates.
Thoughts?