As one last image for tonight, here's a photo of Brizola with his friend and fellow socialist François Mitterrand.

mitterand-e-brizola-Arq-Fam%C3%ADlia-Rabelo-1.jpg


Also, I am unfortunately announcing that I intend to put this timeline on hold for a while. I've been feeling like writing this thing is becoming more like a job rather than a way to kill time, and I intend to start writing a new TL on Pre 1900, on a certain country and age that is completely outside of my comfort zone.

HOWEVER, that does not mean that I'm cancelling this TL, oh hell no. I intend to take this thing to 2016/2018 at the very least.

Goodbye everyone, I'll be back. I don't know when, but I'll return.
 
(2) IOTL, Thomas Sankara was assassinated in a coup d'état in 1987 by one of his closest lieutenants, Blaise Compaoré, who proceeded to rule Burkina Faso as an "ordinary" dictator and reversed his predecessor's policies. Spoiler warning, I guess, but Sankara will be seen by this universe in a much less favourable light.
Ow. Kinda spoiled my awe in seeing Sankara surviving in this TL. I guess that it will be less of a "the could-have been great hero finish the job" type of survival and more of the "die a hero or live long enough to become the villain" one, right?
 
The United States will NOT take too kindly of Brizola pivoting away from the West.
The current US administration, led by president Jerry "Moonbeam" Brown, couldn't care less about Brizola's foreign policy. Since he was elected as a blowback against Reagan's extremely dodgy foreign policy (selling weapons to a mortal enemy and using the money to fund terrorists in Nicaragua), Brown is instead trying to reconcile his country with Latin America's various Pink Tide governments, especially with Daniel Ortega. Neocons like Eliot Abrams and whatnot are probably screaming bloody murder, but they're irrelevant, at least for now.

Ow. Kinda spoiled my awe in seeing Sankara surviving in this TL. I guess that it will be less of a "the could-have been great hero finish the job" type of survival and more of the "die a hero or live long enough to become the villain" one, right?
The thing about Sankara is that he was murdered just in time for his great deeds to take effect (outlawing genital mutilation, agricultural self sufficiency, ordering the planting of ten million trees to fight desertification, land reform, etc) but before his bad ones (outlawing of trade unions, executions, the dismissal of thousands of teachers after a strike, among others) could really be remembered. In the end, it is simply inevitable that such levels of repression will lead to decreased transparency and high levels of corruption, though since Sankara wouldn't reverse his own policies, Burkina Faso will be in a much better place ITTL. However, since Compaoré will never take power, we won't know that.

You can also bet that he will have a legion of internet apologists. After all, if Assad and Maduro, who didn't do anything other than destroy their own countries, have plenty of (twitter) supporters, what's keeping a guy like Thomas from one-upping them and becoming a great leader of the Third World?
 
This is a lie...?

A brazillian TL that it's alive! :p, i can't believe but...instantly watched! Keep it up
It's currently on hold, since I'm busy writing a TL about another part of history that is sorely overlooked, I think (the Crisis of the Third Century), but it's definitely not dead.

And thanks for the watch! I will to the best of my ability.
 
Part 4: 1990 Elections, Part One
------------------
Part 4: 1990 Elections, Part One

Everyone knew what the results of the 1990 gubernatorial elections would look like in the state of Rio de Janeiro. An impregnable PTB stronghold where 75% of its voters went for Brizola just one year ago, everyone knew that the party would sail by this event without a major challenge and secure a third term, controlling one of Brazil's most populous states for the next four years. Even the most ardent right winger knew that whoever they campaigned and voted for would be nothing more than a sacrificial lamb, and thus, the main conservative parties such as PFL, PMB, PDS, among others, barely spent a penny in funding for local campaigns in here, which was a death sentence to whoever aspired to capture the Palácio Guanabara from the petebistas.

The man who was chosen to lead this very unenviable task was Sérgio Cabral Filho, a city councillor from the capital and son of the famous journalist Sérgio Cabral, who was a colleague of people such as Ziraldo and Tarso de Castro, among many others, who worked for O Pasquim, a satirical newspaper that mocked the dictatorship in the 1970s. A member of PFL, he knew that he would be crushed, but this didn't prevent him from campaigning all over the state and spreading his message with every ounce of energy he had.


Although it was quite predictable, the race had one big surprise coming from PTB, the big favourite. Everyone believed that their candidate would be Noel de Carvalho, former mayor of Resende and incumbent governor thanks to Darcy Ribeiro's resignation on the begining of the year. However, much to everyone's surprise, he was upstaged by Jorge Roberto Silveira, the 38 year old former mayor of Niterói, during the convention that nominated who would become the party's candidate. Reportedly tempted to cry foul and complain to the national directory of the party, he decided to stay silence and gear up for the 1992 mayoral elections, where he could hopefully become mayor of Resende for a second time and from there run for the governorship a second time.

Rio de Janeiro 1990.PNG


The results were just as the polls predicted, and Silveira became the third member of his family to be elected governor, a long time dream of his. The seat was occupied first by his uncle, Roberto Silveira, who tragically died in a helicopter accident in 1961 (he was just 37) and later by his uncle Badger da Silveira, who was deposedby the 1964 coup d'état along with several other governors and politicians. Jorge's victory proved to the state and country that his surname was still as powerful as ever.

As for Cabral, he gracefully conceded and swore that he would not abandon politics so soon. How could he, when his career just started (1)?

------------------

Naturally, the eyes of most of the media and the public would always be directed at São Paulo, the wealthiest and most populous state in Brazil. The campaign in there would be nothing more than deeply exciting, for although Collor won it by ten points one year ago, the right was by now fractured between two major candidates that often took potshots at each other: Paulo Maluf (PFL) and the incumbent Wadih Helu (PMB) who was Silvio Santos' lieutenant until he resigned to run for president, and now desired a full term for himself. The tensions from 1989 were still very fresh, and the feud between Santos and Maluf, which cost the former a place in the runoff, was not over and created a toxic pissing contest that damaged both of their respective campaigns.

Meanwhile, the bulk of the left was largely united behind one candidate, the former mayor of Santo André Celso Daniel, who was one of the first members of PT to lead a municipal administration back in 1982. Taking advantage of the civil war in the right, the petista focused on showing off just how great its candidate was, and there was no better way of doing that than highliting the very issue that made the former mayor so famous during his mayoral tenure: participatory budgeting. This unprecedented use of direct democracy led to a direct improvement in the standard of living of the people of Santo André, and won international acclaim before being copied by the mayors of foreign cities such as Lima's Alfonso Barrantes Lingán, and Daniel unexpectedly became sort of an international celebrity, so to speak (2).

These efforts paid off, and the PT candidate won a spot in the gubernatorial runoff, with Paulo Maluf being his opponent. From there, however, the once optimistic campaign became increasingly negative, as the left portrayed Daniel as the only one who could prevent the corrupt lapdog of the dictatorship from becoming governor once more. Meanwhile, Maluf and his allies also went on the offensive, accusing their opponent's platform of being a bunch of utopian ideas that couldn't become reality even in their wildest dreams. Predictably, the voters didn't take the mudslinging very well, and by the last week of the runoff both candidates were on a dead heat.

Fearing that they could lose a chance to win the richest state in the country and become incredibly powerful in the Brizola administration, the petistas made a final, Herculean effort that counted with multiple rallies and marches all over São Paulo, from the capital and its left-leaning surroundings to the largely rural and conservative interior. They also toned down on their attacks and once again framed their campaign as being one of "hope and change", but whether this approach would be effective after weeks of mutual attacks remained to be seen.

São Paulo 1990.PNG


In the end, Maluf's reputation as a corrupt politician proved to be too much even for voters that were skeptical of PT. Though he would run for many offices after his defeat, he would never recover the power that he once had during the dictatorship, and soon his corruption would come to haunt him in the future. As for Daniel and his supporters, they were ecstatic, and had every reason to be. The former mayor had become the party's first state governor ever, and his already prestigious position within PT would grow stronger and stronger as time went on. Some even had the gall to say that he would eventually be able to replace Lula as the party's leader, an outrageous idea that he fervently denied, but was still speculated by many.

------------------
Notes:

(1) That's right, I'm not going to just nip Sérgio Cabral's career in the bud, that would be too easy. He's still going to blow himself up eventually, the only question is when.


(2) When Olívio Dutra first introduced PB to Porto Alegre after he was elected in 1988 IOTL, the same thing happened to him. One of his more famous foreign copycats was the mayor of Buenos Aires, a guy named Fernando de la Rúa. I wonder what happened to him...
 
Nope: Electing Celso Daniel to a higher office.
Woke: With Dr. Geraldo as his running mate.
Bespoke: In 1990.

Nice to see Daniel into this TL because he's one of the most "what-if"-esque politicians in our history (like Eduardo Campos, Tancredo Neves - who already made his cameo here, Enéas Carneiro, etc.), but also had made IOTL a good job into Santo André's mayorship and probably he would draw by his hand together with Lula and FHC the ways that the petismo will follow under the 90s TTL.

Good work, Vini. ;)
 
Nope: Electing Celso Daniel to a higher office.
Woke: With Dr. Geraldo as his running mate.
Bespoke: In 1990.

Nice to see Daniel into this TL because he's one of the most "what-if"-esque politicians in our history (like Eduardo Campos, Tancredo Neves - who already made his cameo here, Enéas Carneiro, etc.), but also had made IOTL a good job into Santo André's mayorship and probably he would draw by his hand together with Lula and FHC the ways that the petismo will follow under the 90s TTL.

Good work, Vini. ;)
Hahaha, I was hoping that someone would notice that!

I was thinking that, since PSDB is a bit more left-wing ITTL (not by much, though) and Alckmin used to be mayor of Pindamonhangaba from 1977 to 1982, he would be a decent bridge between PT and the conservatives who might be a bit hesitant about Daniel (and Lula) but also hate Maluf. It's also a way of healing the rift that almost allowed said politician of Lebanese descent to become mayor of Sampa for a second time in 1988 ITTL.
 
Last edited:
Hahaha, I was hoping that someone would notice that!

I was thinking that, since PSDB is a bit more left-wing ITTL (not by much, though) and Alckmin used to be mayor of Pindamonhangaba from 1977 to 1982, he would be a decent bridge between PT and the conservatives who might be a bit hesitant about Daniel (and Lula) but also hate Maluf. It's also a way of healing the rift that almost allowed said politician of Lebanese descent to become mayor of Sampa for a second time in 1988.

1992, I guess (the year that Maluf defeated Eduardo Suplicy and then four years later launching his padawan Celso Pitta for Mayor...)
 
1992, I guess (the year that Maluf defeated Eduardo Suplicy and then four years later launching his padawan Celso Pitta for Mayor...)
Eh? I meant 1988 ITTL, and I edited the post to prevent any misunderstanding. Speaking of Celso Pitta, could you imagine what could have happened if he wasn't so awful? Maybe Maluf would have become governor in 1998 (shudders)...

Even if that nipped PSDB's dominance (which led to João Dória of all people becoming governor) in the bud Maluf was just so... well, Maluf, that even Mr. Picolé de Chuchu's mismanagement and corruption looks better than that.
 
Last edited:
Eh? I meant 1988 ITTL, and I edited the post to prevent any misunderstanding. Speaking of Celso Pitta, could you imagine what could have happened if he wasn't so awful? Maybe Maluf would have become governor in 1998 (shudders)...

Even if that nipped PSDB's dominance (which led to João Dória of all people becoming governor) in the bud Maluf was just so... well, Maluf, that even Mr. Picolé de Chuchu's mismanagement and corruption looks better than that.

Oh, I didn't saw that, sorry. Well, Pitta at the moment he was elected Mayor of São Paulo he had a initial prospection to be somehow influent to run for Senate (as Maluf never would hand the Governorship to him so easy) or even to the Presidency, if not in '98 but in 2002. But his awful touch to govern and the scandals plus the troubles with his wife ruined his career.

And OTL the tucanos improved that "familiar" feeling as Maluf created inside rural São Paulo (along a decent support in the megalopolis too). Covas' leadership was quite historical from '64 coup d'état from redemocratization and later his establishment as a 'national-regional' political. José Serra was the PSDB's John McCain for a entire decade. Geraldo Alckmin despite his losses in '06 (presidential) and '08 (mayoral) managed to win two times both in the first round. And only by Dória's flip-flop along the OTL bolsonarismo won 2018. I guess the manager-not-politician guy hasn't a place together with ITTL tucanos, isn't? :D
 
Part 5: 1990 Elections, Part Two
-------------------
Part 5: 1990 Elections, Part Two


Since the 1970s, Bahia had been under the iron grip of a powerful oligarch named Antônio Carlos Magalhães (or just ACM), a hardened political veteran whose career started in the 1950s, when he was elected a federal deputy as a member of the National Democratic Union (UDN). His power reached new heights after 1964 coup d'état, and his support of the dictatorship was rewarded first with him being appointed mayor of Salvador in 1967 and from using his new position to become governor of Bahia three years later. Since then, all of the governors and most of the mayors and congressmen were allies of his, and ACM's control of state politics, with a few exceptions, seemed absolute. The return of democracy seemed to do little to weaken him, and he not only became a senator in 1982, but also managed to have two allies of his be elected governor that same year and mayor of Salvador in 1985 (Clériston Andrade and Edvaldo Brito, respectively).

Then everything changed in 1986. That year, a small plurality of the baianos (around 38% of them) made Waldir Pires, a member of PTB and a bitter enemy of ACM and PDS, their governor. Waldir's political career also started in the 1950s, when he first became a congressman, and he almost won the 1962 gubernatorial election, which he lost by just three percentage points. With the rise of the dictatorship, he fled into exile and only returned to active politics in 1982, when he was elected federal deputy under the banner of PMDB, which he abandoned along with several other progressives after the announcement of the Plano Cruzado and its austerity measures. His victory was considered a great upset, and he was considered as a potential running mate for Leonel Brizola in 1989, something that he quickly refused, stating that, although honoured, he had to fight for the people of Bahia and ensure that ACM never came back (1).

The elation from this victory was quickly replaced by turbulence: although he no longer had a governor on his side, ACM still had most mayors and a majority of the Legislative Assembly under his control, which ensured that any promising new measures of his would never be enacted. As Rio de Janeiro and other states ruled by PTB built dozens and eventually hundreds of CIEPs, among other things, Waldir was busy enough just ensuring that the assemblymen didn't just impeach him for some ridiculous reason, which cut into his popularity among the people and lowered his approval ratings (2).

By 1990, it seemed that certain that ACM would return to the governorship without any difficulty at all, and no runoff would be required. Naturally, people were shocked when the living institution that he was fell short of the magic number of 50+1% of the vote to win the race outright, and even more surprised when, during the last days of the runoff, ACM and Waldir were in a dead heat.

Bahia 1990.PNG


The idea that Magalhães could be defeated by a razor-thin margin in a race that he was supposed to win in the first round was unthinkable, and was by far the biggest surprise of election night. There are three main reasons as to why this upset took place: first, although ACM was quite popular in the interior, the populous capital city of Salvador and its surroundings,, absolutely hated his guts and voted en masse for Waldir, as did other important municipalities such as Vitória da Conquista and Feira de Santana. The second one is that Brizola won carried the state in 1989, and most of those who voted for the Old Caudillo voted for his colleague out of loyalty to PTB. The third and probably most important of them is that Magalhães, confident that his victory was guaranteed, didn't campaign as hard as he could have, while Waldir crisscrossed the state and took part in rallies and marches as if his life depended on it.

While ACM would still remain an influential figure in Bahia's politics, his stranglehold over the state apparatus was broken for good.

------------------

Ceará had a very different story to tell, for although the state was under the control of the Três Coronéis (Three Oligarchs) since 1962, their power was falling apart rapidly, and the only reason they controlled the governorship was because of PMDB's unpopularity in 1986, something that not even the popular Tasso Jereissati was able to overcome. Four years after that near miss, the opposition rallied around Ciro Gomes, a young member of PSDB who was elected mayor of Sobral in 1988 and resigned after little more than a year so he could run for governor. The incumbent Adauto Bezerra, who belonged to the infamous trio (César Cals, Virgílio Távora and Bezerra) was facing crisis after crisis, with the capital city of Fortaleza coming dangerously close to running out of water because of a particularly strong drought, and declined to run for reelection due to his unpopularity.

The establishment candidate was Paulo Lustosa, a congressman who served in the previous administrations fulfilling several duties and was rather lackluster to say the least. Ciro, meanwhile, managed to present himself as the candidate of change, something that resonated with the cearense population, tired of being ruled by the same three people since the last twenty-four years. The inconvenient fact that his own family held a great deal of power in Sobral since the 19th century was shoved aside (3).

Ceará 1990.PNG


Predictably, Ciro Ferreira Gomes became governor of Ceará. He was just 31 years old and by far the youngest man to be elected to this office in 1990. This youthfulness, combined with his abrasive style and short temper (to say the least) made him famous not only in the state but also on the rest of Brazil, with media outlets every now and then publishing some of his more incendiary quotes. Though he publicly criticized the media for this behavior (he said that his most explosive quotes were often taken out of context), he couldn't, privately, help but notice that this fame could help him satisfy his great ambitions.

------------------

When one talks about local strongmen, there is one state in Brazil that is the poster child of the coronelismo phenomenon: Maranhão. One of the poorest states in the country, it was dominated by the powerful PDS senator José Sarney, whose allies control the governorship since 1965, when José was elected to the post as a member of UDN. Before that, Maranhão was ruled by another senator, Vitorino Freire, who controlled it through various cronies for twenty years (from 1945 to 1965). Such stagnation unsurprisingly led to extremely high levels of corruption, and the consequences of that were unfortunately just as predictable: its infrastructure was woefully underdeveloped, its illiteracy ratings were among the highest in all of Brazil, and most of of its schools (epecially the public ones) were built out of clay and mud with roofs made out of straw.

All in all, the state looked more like a dystopian country, with millions of people suffering under the grip of a corrupt dictator, a system that lasted for decades and seemed impossible to defeat. That seemed to be the case in 1990, as the incumbent governor, João Castelo, one of Sarney's closest allies, seemed set to win a second consecutive term, even though his tenure was plagued with corruption scandals that made headlines all over Brazil. However, Maranhão was not free from the wave of democratization that swept the rest of the country, and no regime, no matter how powerful, lasts forever.

That is the lesson that the maranhense voters taught when in October 3, when they prevented Castelo from winning the race outright and forced him into a runoff. His opponent was Jackson Lago, a doctor and member of PTB who was mayor of São Luís from 1985 to 1988 (4). What seemed to be a cakewalk slipped from the governor's grasp, as it became clear that Sarney's viceroy was nowhere near ready for a prolonged campaign.


Maranhão 1990.PNG


In the end, though Lago's victory was still a mighty feat, few were surprised. The people of Maranhão, much like those from other states, were tired of being led by the same people for decades on end. Though the oligarchy had been defeated for now, it was time for the new governor to show what he was made of and give one ob Brazil's poorest states a better future (5).

------------------
Notes:

(1) IOTL, Waldir Pires was elected governor of Bahia with an impressive 67% of the vote. However, he resigned to become Ulysses Guimarães' running mate in 1989 and the governorship was taken over by his lieutenant Nilo Coelho, who proved himself to be as corrupt and incompetent as possible. Predictably, ACM returned to the governorship in 1990 in the first round.

(2) Coronéis and their mannerisms.

(3) That's not an exaggeration, since the first mayor of Sobral, back in the 1890s, was a guy named Vicente Cesar Ferreira Gomes.

(4) IOTL, Jackson Lago is a bit of a tragic figure. Elected mayor of São Luís in 1988 IOTL, he ran for the governorship four times. In his third attempt, in 2006,he narrowly defeated former governor Roseana Sarney, who was widely expected to win in the first round, becoming the first governor in 40 to not be one of José Sarney's many cronies. However, he was overthrown in 2009 on very sketchy charges (once again, coronéis and their mannerisms) and died of prostate cancer in 2011.

(5) In other words, the Sarney oligarchy is kicked out of Maranhão twenty-four years before OTL.
 
Last edited:
Will we see a EU-ish MERCOSUL?
ALADI will be a bit more important than OTL, thanks to the fact that NAFTA was avoided. As for Mercosul, it might be a bit more closely integrated, but not by much. There still are a lot of competing interests in it, so most of said extra integration will be of a cultural nature.
 
Top