Inspired by the overweight and bearded president threads, try to make a cohesive list of POTUSes who have seen combat while in military service.
Rules are similar to the others
1) Maximum of 3 terms per President
2) Try to keep it to mainstream parties and only 3 other parties if you provide a good case.
3) If an otl civilian is born with/or develops a condition or defect that keeps them from seeing combat, it cannot be butterflied.
4) Unless they were in combat and interested in politics, no celebrities w/o a good case.
5) Services included: Army, Navy, Marines, Air Force, National Guard, reserves, pre-NG militia, Coast Guard, and as Government employee Bonus if they've received a Medal of Honor or other prestigious award.
6) Can start and end wherever between 1789 and the present.
Here's a quick one. Please feel free to critique.
William McKinley (R-OH) 1897-1901 (Assassinated)
Theodore Roosevelt (R-NY) 1901-1909
Joseph B. Foraker (R-OH) 1909-1913
Theodore Roosevelt (P-NY) 1913-1917
Leonard Wood (R-NH) 1917-1925
Herbert Hoover (D-CA) 1925-1933 (Aided U.S. Marines during the Boxer Rebellion in China. Was offered the Democratic nomination in 1920.)
Henry S. Breckinridge (D-NY) 1933-1937 (Commanded a battalion during WWI, not much information other than that)
Theodore Roosevelt II (R-NY) 1937-1944 (Died of a heart attack)
Charles P. Taft II (R-OH) 1944-1949 (Again, not much information except that he served in WWI)
Harry S. Truman (D-MO) 1949-1953
Harold Stassen (R-MN) 1953-1957
John F. Kennedy (D-MA) 1957-1965 (Was Adlai Stevenson's VP-elect when the Illinois Governor died of a heart attack)
George Wallace (D-AL) 1965-1969 (Governor Wallace defeated Kennedy's pick Senator Johnson after claiming Johnson had lied about his combat service)
Henry Cabot Lodge Jr. (R-MA) 1969-1977
George McGovern (D-SD) 1977-1981
George H.W. Bush (R-TX) 1981-1989
Alexander Haig (R-PA) 1989-1993 (Haig became deeply unpopular for undoing much of the detente McGovern and Bush had done and many believed he had brought the country closer to War than any President since Wallace)
Robert Kerrey (D-NE) 1993-2001
Colin Powell (R-NY) 2001-2005 (After the capture of Osama Bin Laden three years after the terrorist attacked America, Powell announced he would not seek a second term)
John S. McCain (R-AZ) 2005-2013
Tammy Duckworth (D-IL) 2013-Present (First female President, first double amputee President.)
Rules are similar to the others
1) Maximum of 3 terms per President
2) Try to keep it to mainstream parties and only 3 other parties if you provide a good case.
3) If an otl civilian is born with/or develops a condition or defect that keeps them from seeing combat, it cannot be butterflied.
4) Unless they were in combat and interested in politics, no celebrities w/o a good case.
5) Services included: Army, Navy, Marines, Air Force, National Guard, reserves, pre-NG militia, Coast Guard, and as Government employee Bonus if they've received a Medal of Honor or other prestigious award.
6) Can start and end wherever between 1789 and the present.
Here's a quick one. Please feel free to critique.
William McKinley (R-OH) 1897-1901 (Assassinated)
Theodore Roosevelt (R-NY) 1901-1909
Joseph B. Foraker (R-OH) 1909-1913
Theodore Roosevelt (P-NY) 1913-1917
Leonard Wood (R-NH) 1917-1925
Herbert Hoover (D-CA) 1925-1933 (Aided U.S. Marines during the Boxer Rebellion in China. Was offered the Democratic nomination in 1920.)
Henry S. Breckinridge (D-NY) 1933-1937 (Commanded a battalion during WWI, not much information other than that)
Theodore Roosevelt II (R-NY) 1937-1944 (Died of a heart attack)
Charles P. Taft II (R-OH) 1944-1949 (Again, not much information except that he served in WWI)
Harry S. Truman (D-MO) 1949-1953
Harold Stassen (R-MN) 1953-1957
John F. Kennedy (D-MA) 1957-1965 (Was Adlai Stevenson's VP-elect when the Illinois Governor died of a heart attack)
George Wallace (D-AL) 1965-1969 (Governor Wallace defeated Kennedy's pick Senator Johnson after claiming Johnson had lied about his combat service)
Henry Cabot Lodge Jr. (R-MA) 1969-1977
George McGovern (D-SD) 1977-1981
George H.W. Bush (R-TX) 1981-1989
Alexander Haig (R-PA) 1989-1993 (Haig became deeply unpopular for undoing much of the detente McGovern and Bush had done and many believed he had brought the country closer to War than any President since Wallace)
Robert Kerrey (D-NE) 1993-2001
Colin Powell (R-NY) 2001-2005 (After the capture of Osama Bin Laden three years after the terrorist attacked America, Powell announced he would not seek a second term)
John S. McCain (R-AZ) 2005-2013
Tammy Duckworth (D-IL) 2013-Present (First female President, first double amputee President.)
Last edited:
