alternatehistory.com
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New profile posts
New threadmarks
Latest activity
Members
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Word Count:
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Members
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
scifilovr's latest activity
scifilovr
replied to the thread
AHQ: How can Russia revitalize itself?
.
Definitely not trying to imply that the Russian peasantry was ignorant or backward or anything of the sort. I can't quote any specific...
Apr 27, 2024
scifilovr
posted the thread
AHQ: How can Russia revitalize itself?
in
Alternate History Discussion: Before 1900
.
I'm currently on a Russian history reading kick and working on an alternate history where I want to give Russia something of a...
Apr 27, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
WI: The US Navy Goes For Nuclear Seaplane Bombers Instead Of Nuclear Submarines?
.
Doesn't have a snowballs chance in hell from taking away funding from carrier aviation or submarines, which are the two most powerful...
Apr 22, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Explain the AH Quote
.
Bro, you've got to respond to the last quote given, you totally skipped over the last guy.
Apr 4, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Explain the AH Quote
.
Spoken by US President Lewis Strauss at the funeral of Chaim Rumkowski, former Marshall of the Polish Republic. While his career as an...
Mar 29, 2024
scifilovr
reacted to
JasTysoe's post
in the thread
How "should" WWII in 1940 have gone?
with
Like
.
Isn't it arguable that both the Germans and the Japanese favoured high-risk strategies that paid very little attention to logistics and...
Mar 27, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Explain the AH Quote
.
English expat Professor James Ingersoll, speaking at the 1977 Center for Strategic Objectivism. In 1929, following the Mundial War...
Mar 7, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Operation FS and the Kantai Kessen carrier battle in August 1942
.
I should have specified, I expect its more likely for more Japanese carriers to be hit. During most of the carrier battles, each side...
Feb 28, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Operation FS and the Kantai Kessen carrier battle in August 1942
.
What happens next after this hypothetical battle? I think the general consensus is both sides take pretty good punches; two to three...
Feb 27, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Operation FS and the Kantai Kessen carrier battle in August 1942
.
But would the IJN know about this? It’s the difference between Yamamoto thinking he’s bringing four against two versus four on four or...
Feb 27, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Operation FS and the Kantai Kessen carrier battle in August 1942
.
I was speaking about Yamamoto’s perspective. He believes he’s sunk two American carriers and there should only be two left. Can he know...
Feb 26, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Operation FS and the Kantai Kessen carrier battle in August 1942
.
That sounds like the RN was using courts martial as impromptu courts of inquiry, vice criminal proceedings (except in a few cases...
Feb 26, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Operation FS and the Kantai Kessen carrier battle in August 1942
.
If you court martial every officer for failing in combat, especially at the beginning of the war, then you remove any possibility for...
Feb 26, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Operation FS and the Kantai Kessen carrier battle in August 1942
.
The USN does have a bad habit of giving a lot of deference to upper ranks and a definite reluctance to punish senior commanders or...
Feb 26, 2024
scifilovr
replied to the thread
Operation FS and the Kantai Kessen carrier battle in August 1942
.
I'm unable to find an exact timeline of the events leading up to the bombing of Franklin, I'd probably have to try and track down the...
Feb 26, 2024
Members
Top